Pseudo-Science in South Africa

Pseudo-Science in South Africa


Washington Post- Tuesday , April 18, 2000


PERHAPS THE most important result of the World Bank-IMF meetings was that, for the first time, the final communique paid

due respect to the debilitating importance of AIDS. Yet even as the bankers spoke, on the other side of the world, President

Thabo Mbeki of South Africa was taking a further step down a path that will make the scourge worse. The Washington

meetings recognized that no country can develop if a large chunk of its work force is sick, if millions of children grow up

orphans and if national budgets are swamped by the cost of care for the dying. But Mr. Mbeki seems undeterred.


South Africa is in the midst of a medical holocaust. Some 10 percent of the country's 44 million people are HIV-positive. A

government study found 22.8 percent of all pregnant women carrying the virus, which causes AIDS; at that rate, an estimated

5,000 South African babies are born HIV-positive every month. Thanks to inadequate health care, poor education and social

stigma, many, many infected people receive only partial treatment or none.


Yet President Mbeki unaccountably continues to embrace and legitimize absolute misinformation about the causes and

treatment of AIDS. In 1997, while still Nelson Mandela's deputy president, he supported the use of a spurious South

African-made remedy for AIDS called Virodene. Last year, his government refused to fund distribution of the medication AZT

to pregnant women, despite the fact that it has been shown to reduce the transmission of HIV from pregnant mothers to their

babies. Mr. Mbeki labeled the medicine "a danger to health" and derided his critics as "salespersons" for the manufacturer.


It is not clear why Mr. Mbeki continues to evade the reality. His latest idea is to convene an international panel to reexamine the

cause of AIDS. The panel will include "dissident" academics who claim, among other things, that Africa's epidemic is a result of

malnutrition rather than infection by HIV. "You can't respond correctly [to the AIDS epidemic] by closing your eyes and ears

to any point of view," Mr. Mbeki says. Actually, the president's panel is a ludicrous waste of precious time, and a cruel hoax on

his suffering people. No serious medical scientist doubts the causal link between HIV and AIDS. And no serious political

leader should either.


2000 The Washington Post Company